What went wrong for England in this tour to India

Posted by

India were too good for England, even though they came with high expectations after their heroics in the 2012 test series in India. This time, they were not the settled or experienced team as the last squad that visited the country.  Cricket-21 takes a look at such factors that cost England the test series.

One too many left-handers

The New Zealand tour of India test series showed Ashwin’s prowess against left handers. England, knowing full well that India would be attempting to bowl Ashwin at all their left-handers, landed in India with eight left-handers. Their typical playing XI had five left-handers, all of whom reflected in Ashwin’s wicket tally for the series.

Gary Ballance, who did not get one game in the first four test matches , could have been left-out for a right-hander, maybe the experienced Ian Bell, or even Sam Billings who played in India during the Indian Premier League.

Ashwin vs LHB and RHB in this series

Vulnerable Middle Order

England’s 2012 batting line-up had reliable and experienced cricketers. They had Trott, Pietersen, Bell, Prior coming one after the other. Not to forget that they opened with Strauss and Cook.

Pietersen was a pivotal player in that series, he served as an attacking option at number four. The Mumbai test where he scored a blistering century was a testament to how flustered the Indian spinners get when they are attacked with intent.

England had Duckett batting at No.4 for the first two tests in this series. Neither him, nor his replacement Moeen Ali  are such belligerent batsmen. Maybe Buttler would have been a good pick at number four.

Root could be a typical replacement for Trott, at #3, when he is able to convert his half centuries into big scores.

England still won three tosses in the first four games, a big score from any of their batsman could have changed the outlook of the series.

England’s Top 4 Batsmen – Performances in 2012 and 2016

Doubts over Cook’s captaincy

On hindsight, there are some decisions that Cook might rethink. At Rajkot with India reeling, Kohli managed to secure a draw after scoring a fifty and setting up a partnership with the lower order. Maybe England could have declared 10 to 15 overs before they did.

Cook’s deployment of pacers and spinners came into question many times throughout the series. England had India on backfoot quite a few times and they were also ahead while starting sessions. Too many times Cook didn’t bring out his strike bowlers Adil Rashid or Moeen Ali, instead bowled the likes of Gareth Batty or Ansari.

And when the injured Zafar Ansari was to be replaced, England brought in Liam Dawson into the squad, but he was not played in the XI for the fourth test. Maybe a left-arm spinner, like Dawson or Jadeja, who picked six wickets in the fourth test, would have been more useful than a fast bowling all-rounder at Mumbai.

Even now, at the eve of the fifth test, it is not clear which English spinners would be playing except Adil Rashid and Moeen Ali.

 

Should Dhoni Bat at #4?

Reliability | India have lost only 3 in 19 games when Dhoni has scored 30+ while batting at ...

Learn more

NZ v SA – 2nd ODI – INSIGHTS

South Africa’s tactics against Ross Taylor Ross Taylor produced a match-winning century, ...

Learn more

NZ v SA – 4th ODI – INSIGHTS

Unusual Slow Pitch in New Zealand - Spinners opening with the new ball in the 1st innings ...

Learn more

Cricket-21 BBL Fantasy XI – Round 8

Round 8, the last round before the semi-finals of the BBL 6th edition is here and it features ...

Learn more

The Start of Kohli Era

Captain Kohli |Kohli has the best 50 to 100 conversion rate of 62.5 as captain in ODIs. He is ...

Learn more

Winner Takes All Showdown at Eden Park

The deciding match of the ODI series between New Zealand and South Africa comes back to Eden ...

Learn more

How big a Miss is James Anderson?

James Anderson, since his debut in 2003, has missed only 28 test matches. The 119 matches he ...

Learn more

South Africa on the verge of creating history

South Africa takes on New Zealand for the first time at Hagley Oval in the second ODI of the ...

Learn more

Five Series Wins and Counting

India sit pretty atop the test rankings after dismantling England in the fourth test of the ...

Learn more

IND v ENG – 2nd ODI – Insights

The Calm before the Storm Walking in within the first five overs, a cool head like Dhoni ...

Learn more